Since I started wearing winged liner years and years ago, I used the Collection 2000 Fast Stroke liner but a few months back, it started to fade on me and easily move. I don't know what happened, perhaps they changed the formula or maybe it was the weather. In search for a new liner that would be good for everyday wear, and most importantly, a liquid liner with a felt applicator (I sincerely dislike brush applicators, they just don't provide enough precision for me.) I found the L'Oreal Super Liner Black Lacquer. I'm glad that I did because this stuff does not move, the brush is beautiful for getting a perfect wing and the result is very dark and very glossy. I really love this product.
What you should bare in mind with this is that it is quite difficult to get off, but that sort of proves its staying power! Very glad I've found this, it's my new holy grail liquid liner.
Seize the Beautiful xo